Frozen snapshot · version 1

Current version · Pinned JSON

Prometheanism

I listened to this podcast by Protocol Labs founder Juan Benet. He was talking to Allison Duettmann of the Foresight Institute. They talk about a lot of things, but I guess you could say the heart of it was optimism. Duettmann calls it Existential Hope. Benet talked about is as the Myth of Prometheus.

The big idea is that there are technologies and fields of science that could open up new possibilities for humans, better ways to live, more experiences. What is some real work that's happening now that fits into this idea of believing that it's worth making the world better? 

I'd start with AI-assisted protein design, which opens up possibilities for new medicines, and gene editing, which has already reached patients with inherited diseases. For the literal Promethean project of giving humanity more usable energy, solar and battery storage offer plenty to explore. Those would be my entry points: fields with tangible progress and enormous room for people to build something useful.

That's great. But it still seems kind of pedestrian. Things people already know about. 

What would you say are the fields that have begun but are a little over the horizong for most people? The kind of things that scientists and researchers currently think "we can do this" but other people might look at and say "that's impossible." 

I feel like there's a lot of people out there who believe humans shouldn't even try pursuing ideas that look too hard, as if it's a waste of resources that could be applied elsewhere. Pesonally I find this worldview dispiriting, but it's prevalent.

I'd look at building living cells from molecular parts, restoring movement after paralysis through electronic bridges between brain and spine, and making fusion a practical power source. We already have working pieces of synthetic cells, a brain–spine interface that restored walking in one participant, and repeated fusion ignition—though each remains far from its ultimate promise. These are fields where "can this happen?" is giving way to "how far can we take it?" Scarcity demands judgment about which bets to fund; it doesn't make difficulty itself an argument against trying.

I agree! 

OK, you've mentioned a couple of medical concepts, but mostly in terms of healing. The stuff you've brought up has all been about getting patients back to homeostasis. What about going beyond homeostasis, though? What about being smarter, stronger, faster or expanding our senses? What about enhancing our experience of the world. 

One really disconnect people seem to have is that it's okay to make a human faster by giving him a motorcycle, but if you do it by literally making his body work better, that's somehow an ethical boundary. 

Like, I get the concern in athletic competition. But what if I want to just live a cooler life and I want my vehicle — my physical body — to be capable of more. Why can't we pursue that? And if we can, what are some promising areas that folks are looking into?

We can pursue that—I don't think restoring an average human baseline is the only legitimate ambition for medicine. Your motorcycle analogy exposes a real inconsistency, although an enhancement's reversibility, risks, and potential for coercion still matter. For a glimpse of what's possible, researchers have demonstrated contact lenses that let people perceive near-infrared signals and an extra robotic thumb that expands a pianist's reach. Those are early demonstrations, but they suggest something more interesting than repair: new senses, new dexterity, perhaps entirely new ways to inhabit a body. Wanting a richer experience of being alive seems like a perfectly legitimate reason to explore.

This framework about the right to pursue ways of imporving one's life is how I think of the current peptides discourse.

A lot of people are taking peptides not to fix something, but to actually be better in some way. To have more energy. To sleep better. To enhance their skin.

This seems to make a lot of clinicians and medical ethicists uneasy, but I think it's fine. Especially if it's something they are doing on their own dime, rather than socializing it. Chairman Birb Bernanke wrote a compelling post on how much good taking peptides did for her, but it's wild how angry people get at the idea that people should be allowed to thoughtfully make experiments on themselves. 

I think the strongest version of your argument is that people shouldn't have to prove they're broken before they're allowed to want something better. More energy, better sleep, or skin you feel happier inhabiting are legitimate aims. "That isn't medically necessary" doesn't, by itself, settle whether someone should be allowed to pursue it.

But I'd separate the right to experiment from confidence in what's being sold. Someone can support bodily autonomy while asking whether a particular peptide works, whether its contents match its label, and whether the seller is honest about uncertainty. Those questions help make experimentation thoughtful. A personal account can be meaningful without establishing what caused the improvement or what someone else should expect.

Paying your own way strengthens the autonomy argument, although it doesn't eliminate every consequence for others. Still, we don't generally demand that people's choices carry zero possible public cost before permitting them.

The useful ethical distinction is between accepting uncertainty for yourself and selling certainty to someone else. Adults deserve substantial freedom to do the first. People making money from their hopes deserve scrutiny over the second.

Scrutiny is fine. The current standard here though is, if it's a drug of any kind, you are absolutely blocked unless it has full FDA-sign off. Which is a lot.

And to your point: No we don't stop people from taking risks. Motorcycles being, again, a great examples. You can own a crotch rocket, even though if you get in a wreck either your insurer or the medical system is likely to pick up part of that cost later on. 

Anyway, enough ethical debates though. Let's say a blogger like me wanted to get more serious about studying this world of contemporary Prometheanism. What are some good topics to study and write about that might deepen my own understanding but also help me to find interesting stories to pursue? Stuff that I could make explain for regular people that they might not realize how much promise it's showing?

I'd start with how the brain learns to use new capabilities. The extra-thumb work we discussed gets more interesting when you look beyond the gadget: in a study involving 596 people, almost everyone could manipulate objects with it within their first minute. That gives you a terrific reporting question: how much of having "only two hands" is anatomy, and how much is what we've had the opportunity to learn? Follow the researchers studying practice, coordination and embodiment—the process by which a tool starts feeling like part of you.

Then explore engineering better learning and sleep. Researchers studying targeted memory reactivation use cues associated with earlier learning to influence which memories strengthen during sleep. This isn't downloading French overnight; it's an experimental foothold on improving something our brains already do. There's a fascinating story in what actually transfers beyond a laboratory task: could someone retain vocabulary, musical skills or professional training more effectively without spending more waking hours studying?

Finally, follow wearable strength and endurance. A 2024 exoskeleton study reduced the energy people expended walking, running and climbing stairs compared with wearing no device. That suggests stories about hiking farther, carrying equipment or finishing a physically demanding day with something left in the tank. Across these fields, your best recurring question is: "What can a person demonstrably do now, and what still prevents an ordinary person from doing it?" That gap is full of interesting engineering, human experiences and businesses worth investigating.

Not a bad start. I dig it. I was hoping you were going to get into nanotechnology or maybe — I don't know — teleportation? Why not! But I'll take it. Good chat, robot.

—Brady Dale
October 29, 2026