Frozen snapshot · version 1

Current version · Pinned JSON

Stub of: A worldview defined by pity makes life for the person with that view terrible and it doesn't seem to do much good for anyone else.

I appreciate this critique:

Pity does sound like a futile emotion, but the adjacent stance of compassion is anything but. In fact it has driven much of the improvement in the human condition in the last few centuries. Nietzscheans otoh have been mostly strutting around like Pete Hegseth circulating silly “strong men create good times” memes and starting bloody wars.

And I have a lot of sympathy for it. Believe me, I worry sometimes that as I drift away from my roots as a young leftist I'm getting attracted to that caricature of the Pete Hegseth'esque idea. And I try to be vigilant about that. 

The reason I keep pushing forward though is because it genuinely doesn't seem like the present politics of compassion is actually doing much good. And I'm pretty convinced that it in fact attracts more people to living lives without dignity.

No argument that the lonely great man isn't a cartoon. I get that criticism, and make no effort to defend it. 

But it's also true that our culture is drifting in ways that appear maladaptive. So, I do think some kind of Hegelian synthesis is hopefully afoot. The seeking toward greatness that can lead to some kind of cultural consensus around an aspirational telos again. This is how I think Nietzsche might, maybe, possibly be useful right now. Maybe he didn't have all of it. Maybe he did have a piece of it?

On the other hand, where I have sympathy for the idea that the rot might be in Nietzsche himself is, well, if you look at his actual life, it was pretty terrible. Why should anyone trust that guy? But I'm playing with his ideas anyway. I feel like there's something there, like this book has endured for a reason.