A moral howler monkey
October of Zarathustra
So the Complete Idiots' Guide to Hegel goes something like this: The world becomes dominated by a big idea, a thesis. That thesis rules the roost for a long time, but eventually there will be iconoclasts, people skeptical of the thesis.
The mainstream will be skeptical of the iconoclasts at first, but their numbers will grow. They will have developed an antithesis. There will be a period of clashing.
Eventually a merging will happen, maybe even a new insight, and that's what's called a synthesis. More than a remix of ideas, at best it's a reinvention. But the core concept is that history is driven by a push-and-pull between ideas.
(I've never been able to follow Hegel beyond the complete idiot's version — best I can do — but I find it useful even if philosophy grad students might grouse about it)
Optimism is a bit of a discursive subtheme right now.
A certain number of people really want to see the world get a lot more optimistic about what's possible. About manufacturing. About technology. About medicine. About more-than-medicine.
And then an enormous contingent of people hate optimism. They find it untoward. It leaves people out. It ignores present conditions. It seems wasteful to even try, because they don't see how it will work.
When I read these two chapters in Thus Spoke Zarathustra, it reminded me of this push and pull. This cycle. In the first chapter, 'Among Daughters of the Wilderness,' it seems like Zarathustra's big idea has gotten through to his acolytes.
Then in the second they are praying to a donkey. He's baffled.
This seems somewhat like the cycle of the world to me. Amid the industrial revolution, we thought anything was possible. There was a spirit of optimism that swept the land. Though we've been living through an age of miracles and wonders for thirty years now, the whole country has never really embraced it. It's lemminged into it, but it never embraced it. The people reluctantly submitted to mind control.
It might be that humans can only handle so much optimism. The truth is most people would like to believe tomorrow will be much like today. Because I didn't die today. If I didn't die today, then today is pretty good. Let's stick with today.
So you can handle optimism for a while but at a certain point the anxiety of change starts to sweep over you and your neighbors.
Maybe the whole 20th century was a hangover of anxiety from those industrial revolution days of optimism? Maybe today's optimistic iconoclasts are the ones working out a new antithesis.
Here's my antithesis (and I really think it's right): The best way to solve present problems is not, in fact, by seeking solutions. The best way to solve present problems is by pursuing new creations.
Among the Daughters of the Wilderness
Zarathustra's shadow sings a song about how great Zarathustra is. He is really obsessed with how good air feels, which is a sharp contrast to how Zarathustra had been talking about the air inside the cave being bad. Apparently his guests don't see it that way! At least the shadow thinks everyone smells great.
The Awakening
Zarathustra goes outside to talk to his animals about how it really seems like his acolytes are coalescing into a good spirit and he's glad. They seem thankful, which is a spirit that will allow them to enter the future in a manly way.
- Only to be disappointed by finding that as soon as he turns his back they all start praying to a donkey.
One line
“You would not believe how charmingly they sat there, when they did not dance, profound, but without thoughts, like little secrets, like ribboned riddles, like after-dinner nuts—“ —Zarathustra’s shadow.
- He's talking about a group of young girls he encountered once.
- Pretty young girls make all the old men of the world crazy. They are weapons of mass destruction to the clarity of men's thinking.
—Brady Dale
October 29, 2026
Versions · current v2 ·
- Version 1 · frozen pin — Imported from 113.html
Next Zarathustra: What does it matter!