But is it gnosis?

Pope Leo XIV recently tweeted that there is "an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others.”
…
Robots wired into the world will soon perceive it for themselves. A robot or AI that learns from its own sensors isn't borrowing images from others. LLMs were founded on our words but their words will dominate the future.
So picture a robot on a beach at dusk. It watches the sun go down, then paints what it saw. Is it art?—marginalrevolution.com

I don't super care about this question, frankly, and I care a lot about human art. Many will quibble about this point. Not me.

But if there's one very much related question about AI that I am curious about, it's what will happen when large models have access to (or in some other way glom with) data and inputs about the real world. Particularly data that has feedback. When they do things in the real world and the real world does back. This is the thing I'm watching the most closely so I can have a look when it really starts to happen. 

It is one thing to have seen every schematic of a chair ever made. It is wholly another thing to sit in a chair, to pick one up, to scooch one out from under a table so someone else can sit down.

I want to see what happens when the machine minds have access to data like that. 

I'm extremely curious about artificial gnosis.

—Brady Dale
October 6, 2026

Versions · current v2 · 2026-10-06
RSS