From xkcd . This isn't really right, but it is helpful in a way. It illuminates how the first amendm

From xkcd.
This isn't really right, but it is helpful in a way. It illuminates how the first amendment somewhat muddles the concept of free speech in the US. I am glad we have it, but it confuses the conversation.
The first amendment is a floor on the concept of freedom of speech. The first amendment only pertains to state action. That doesn't mean that there can't be abridgements on the freedom of speech that the first amendment is silent on.
In fact, specifically as it relates to assholes — to use the comic's language: The truth is, today's asshole is tomorrow's person-who-was-making-a-very-good-point.
I'm reading Anne Brontë's The Tenant of Windfell Hall right now. Early in the book, the tenant, a young widower, Mrs. Graham, creates an uncomfortable scene when she tells her new neighbors that she doesn't approve of giving young boys wine. They all laugh at her. It's really striking to read from 2026. We would all agree that giving wine to children is a bad idea. This has not always been the case. Mrs. Graham made herself a bit of an asshole in that scene, but I don't think she was wrong!
In fact, one of the foundational texts on freedom of speech, On Liberty, by John Stuart Mill, devotes many more pages to how society suppresses freedom of speech (by ostracizing dissenting voices) than it does to state suppression.
Versions · current v1 · 2026-10-05
- Version 1 · frozen pin — 2026-10-05 Fragment from openers.html