Thus Spoke Zarathustra , day 1 — Zarathustra's Prologue George Mason University's Robin Hanson has b

Thus Spoke Zarathustra, day 1 — Zarathustra's Prologue

George Mason University's Robin Hanson has been writing about the slow collapse of Western Civilization. The collapse can be seen right now, he says, in the form of low fertility. If a population doesn't stop shrinking, then that population will go away eventually. 

This is self-evident.

There's a lot of ways to quibble with Hanson's example, but his larger point is that changes in how we live in the West, our values, are no longer governed by selective pressures. In ancient times, cultures pushed right up against each other. They competed with each other for resources. They competed for productivity. They also competed with disease, which was always looking for a reason to kill them.

Culture was, effectively, a set of heuristics that said: If we live this way, we tend to reproduce and also not die. 

Today, in most of the world, you can live your whole life relatively secure that the forces that killed men and women in ancient times (invasions, hunger, disease, brigands) probably won't get you. Your biggest risks come from heart disease (which, to an extent, is a disease of plenty) and car collisions (which is definitely a disease of plenty).

Living without the big risks is no recipe for happiness, precisely, but it is a recipe for contentment. 

And the whole point of the prologue seems to be that it's better to die suddenly from living alive than to live a long time in a slow death.

So Zarathustra comes down off his mountain and tries to tell that to people and they laugh at him and make fun of him.

Of course they do. No one wants to hear that they are living life wrong. 

But even if they did want to hear it, that probably wouldn't help much.

The misery of philosophy is that you can find your way to a deep truth and you can feel that truth in your bones, but you're never going to convey it in words. There's so much that we know that we can't say. We can point to the deep truth we've found, but people won't find it themselves unless they follow where you point and get there themselves through direct experience.

You can read the recipe of the muffin and that won't tell you one single thing about what it will be like to bite into the muffin. It goes even deeper than that. Biting into the muffin made using the same recipe might even vary quite a bit from one baker to another.

Words are low bandwidth. Even if Zarathustra really has cracked the code of death and resurrection, he's doomed never to be able to share that code with anyone else. 

Versions · current v1 · 2026-10-08
RSS