The highest virtue is uncommon and useless

October of Zarathustra

This morning's reading plan for Thus Spoke Zarathustra only had one chapter in it, and it was the last chapter of the first section of the book, "On the Gift-Giving Virtue." 

There's something I didn't notice the first time I read this. It's pretty obvious, but I missed it. If you know anything about the story of Zarathustra, even just from second-hand accounts, you probably know that, at the beginning of the book, Zarathustra comes down off the mountain and then goes right back up it again.

Because no one hears him. No one takes him seriously. They make fun of him.

It's funny.

It's funny because the way these myths usually go, the guru comes out of the wilderness and makes this great revelation and people are like: "Holy crap! He's right!" ::bows down::

But Nietzsche realized that's not how it would work at all. People would just find the guru weird.

Well, fine, but in the last chapter of the first section, you learn that Zarathustra actually does have some followers now. Things have changed. He has enough that he decides to move on, but he also tells the followers not to follow him. To go off on their own. 

Somehow I missed this whole shift previously. I think it was probably because my head was spinning so hard from reading the book, from trying to extract meaning from this very strange, very encoded text.

The way I'm reading it now, I'm trying to make my brain parse every sentence. It's the kind of book that's easy to find yourself reading without really reading. You're passing over the words, but your mind is not really listening. So I try to make myself listen, but other than knowing what each sentence says and maybe stringing the last few together, I don't worry about much else.

That is, I'm not reading for deeper meaning. I'm just trying read the literal, surface meaning of each passage. That's enough. Just attend to what's there. Don't tune out.

What I'm looking for now is a part that makes some memory or idea click. Or for some theme to lift up out of it, like those Magic Eye images that used to be so popular.  

The more I read it, the more convinced I become that Nietzsche was effectively casting a magic spell, wishing for the world to engender more truly unique, truly outstanding individuals to show the way to a more vigorous world, one where everyone would live with more aliveness. 

Maybe I'm not getting it, after all, but that's the one that keeps coming up for me as I read this way. 

One line

“Tell me: how did gold come to have the highest value? Because it is uncommon and useless and shining and soft in luster; it always gives itself.” —Zarathustra.

If you don't tell him about iPhones, I won't.

—Brady Dale
October 7, 2026

Versions · current v6 ·
RSS

Next Zarathustra: Sleeping swords